Guide · Homeowners · 3 min read · Updated 17 November 2026
Aluminium vs uPVC Roof Lanterns: Which Should You Choose?
Short answer
Aluminium roof lanterns have slimmer frames, greater strength for larger spans and a wide choice of powder-coated colours, with thermal breaks to reduce heat loss. They typically cost £2,500–£4,500 for a medium size. uPVC lanterns are cheaper, around £1,200–£2,200 for a small size, and work well on smaller extensions, but have bulkier frames. For large or design-led projects, aluminium is usually the better choice.
Side-by-side comparison
Both aluminium and uPVC lanterns can be well made, energy efficient and watertight. The differences are mainly about appearance, strength over larger spans and price. The right choice depends on the size of the lantern, the style of the property and your budget.
The table summarises the key differences using typical fitted guide prices.
| Feature | Aluminium | uPVC |
|---|---|---|
| Typical price | £2,500–£4,500 medium size | £1,200–£2,200 small size |
| Frame sightlines | Slim, more glass | Bulkier |
| Strength over large spans | High | Lower, often steel or aluminium reinforced |
| Colour choice | Wide range of powder-coated colours | More limited, often white or grey |
| Thermal performance | Good with thermal breaks | Good |
| Best suited to | Larger lanterns, contemporary designs | Smaller extensions, tighter budgets |
Aluminium roof lanterns
Aluminium is strong and stiff for its weight, which allows narrower glazing bars and larger panes of glass. The result is a lantern that looks lighter and lets in more light for the same size. Modern aluminium lanterns are thermally broken, meaning the inner and outer parts of each profile are separated by a low-conductivity insulating strip, cutting heat loss and reducing the cold bridging that causes condensation on frames.
Aluminium is powder-coated in a wide range of colours, and many systems offer different colours inside and out, so you can match anthracite grey windows outside while keeping white frames inside. For lanterns above a certain size, or for bespoke shapes on orangeries, aluminium is often the only practical option.
uPVC roof lanterns
uPVC lanterns use reinforced plastic frames, often with aluminium-capped outer profiles that improve weather resistance and appearance. They offer good thermal performance at a lower price and are well suited to smaller kitchen and garden room extensions.
The main drawbacks are visual. uPVC frames are bulkier, so you get slightly less glass for the same overall size, and colour options are more limited. Over larger spans, uPVC needs more internal reinforcement and may not be suitable at all. For a modest lantern on a budget, though, a well-made uPVC unit can be a sensible choice.
- Lower upfront cost
- Good thermal performance
- Best for smaller lanterns
- Limited colour range
- Thicker frames than aluminium
Glazing options for both
Whichever frame you choose, the glazing matters as much as the frame. Most lanterns use sealed double-glazed units with a toughened outer pane and a laminated inner pane, so that if the glass breaks, the inner pane holds together rather than falling into the room. Triple glazing is available on some systems for extra insulation.
Solar control glass reduces heat gain and glare, which is valuable on south and west-facing lanterns. Self-cleaning coatings on the outer pane help rain wash dirt away. Tinted glass is another option to reduce glare. Your installer should explain the glazing specification clearly in the quote.
Matching your property
Think about how the lantern will look from inside and out. On a modern extension with slim aluminium bifold doors and grey window frames, an aluminium lantern in a matching colour will look coherent. On a traditional property, a lantern with a decorative ridge and finials might suit better. On a small garden room with white uPVC windows, a white uPVC lantern may be the most consistent choice.
Look at the ridge and hip details too. Slim, neatly finished ridges and end caps give a more refined look, while bulky caps can dominate a small lantern.
Consider how the lantern will look from upstairs windows and the garden too, because it is often seen from above. A crisp ridge line and neat flashing around the kerb make a big difference to the finished look. For orangeries and period homes, bespoke shapes such as octagonal ends or Victorian-style ridges are possible, though these are almost always made in aluminium and cost more than standard rectangular units.
Installation quality matters most
A premium aluminium lantern will still leak if the kerb is poorly built or the membrane is badly sealed. Conversely, a modest uPVC lantern on a well-insulated, correctly sealed kerb can perform very well for years. The most common problems with lanterns come from installation: kerbs that are too low, membranes not turned up properly, missing insulation around the upstand and seals that are not correctly fitted.
Ask your installer how they will build and insulate the kerb, how the roof membrane will be finished, and whether the lantern manufacturer's installation instructions will be followed. A neat, well-detailed kerb is a good sign of a careful installer.
Getting advice
Before you decide, ask to see samples of the frame profiles and ridge caps, and if possible look at a finished installation of the system being offered. Check the lantern's thermal performance figures, the glazing specification and the guarantee terms for both the frame and the sealed units. Make sure quotes are for comparable sizes and glazing so you are comparing like with like.
We arrange vetted, insured local lantern installers who can show you frame options, explain glazing choices and recommend aluminium or uPVC based on your extension's size, style and budget.
Questions people also ask
Are aluminium roof lanterns worth the extra cost?
For larger lanterns or contemporary designs, usually yes. Aluminium allows slimmer frames and bigger panes, so more light enters, and offers a wide colour choice. For small lanterns on a budget, a good uPVC lantern can perform well. Installation quality matters as much as frame material.
Do aluminium roof lanterns get condensation?
Modern aluminium lanterns are thermally broken, which greatly reduces cold bridging and frame condensation. Condensation can still occur in very humid rooms, such as kitchens with poor extraction, or if the kerb is not insulated. Good ventilation and an insulated kerb help prevent it.
Can uPVC roof lanterns be coloured?
Some uPVC lanterns are available in colours such as grey or with coloured aluminium caps on the outside, but the range is usually more limited than aluminium. If you want a specific colour or different colours inside and out, aluminium gives more choice.
Written and checked by the Lantern Roof Installation team. Read our editorial policy.
More guides
How Much Does a Roof Lantern Cost in the UK? 2026 Fitted Prices
A small uPVC roof lantern of around 1m by 2m typically costs £1,200–£2,200 fitted onto a ready kerb. A medium aluminium lantern of around 1.5m by…
Do Roof Lanterns Need Building Regulations or Planning Permission?
In England and Wales, installing a replacement rooflight is notifiable building work and must meet Approved Document L energy requirements; it can be…
Roof Lantern vs Flat Rooflight: Which Is Best for Your Extension?
A roof lantern is a pitched, raised glazed structure that brings in light from several angles and adds height and character to a room. A flat…
Roof Lantern Leaking? Causes, Condensation and How to Fix It
Most roof lantern leaks come from the kerb and membrane junction, failed glazing seals, damaged ridge or hip caps, or blocked drainage channels.…
Get a free lantern roof installation quote
Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a clear price.
Request a quote